Case File #375: The Nefarious Agent Dilemma (or, NAD)
Background: Over a year ago, I bought a laptop from Best Buy. Knowing that I'd be bringing this back and forth to work every weekday, I paid for a three year extended warranty that would "fix anything that happens to it, short of you (me) pounding nails through it on purpose"
1. I should state that I have never tested this extreme by
accidentally pounding nails through my laptop, though in case any of you scoff at such an idea, I should point out that I have accidentally nailed a backdrop to a stage, accidentally sawed into a table (with a hand saw, not a power saw), and accidentally received a 3.98 one semester when I handed in all my final exams late, ranging from 2 weeks to 3 months (one professor called that "unusual", and gave me my only A-, resulting in a 3.98 instead of a 4.0)
2.
I have, however, tested the basic premise of this, approximately one year ago, when my power input ceased to function in the proper way. It was still really good at getting incredibly hot, so much so that the cable on my power supply is a little melted, but its primary function, that is, delivering power in any way to my laptop, started to be as successful political ethical reform in New Jersey
3.
I was pleased that I got exactly the service I paid for, though it seemed excessive to me that they, according to their agent, had to replace the whole motherboard. Please note that no mention of warnings, possible problems, or anything similar were given to me before, during, or after this process. In other words, this background has no NADs.
Current Proceedings: My laptop exterior has begun to split apart. While it still functions properly, and I've used it for some time, I'm worried since the damage seems to be progressing. I did not get it fixed during the school year because after my desktop died
4 I had no way of actually doing any work without it. This summer had been too busy, but now that I bask in the joy of unemployment while my girlfriend works from 7:30 am - 6:00 pm every day, I figure I can spare a little time
5.
So I traveled to a Best Buy, and therein approached their resident Geek Squad Station. Little did I know I was about to confront a NAD.
I should have been tipped off! While waiting in line, this agent advised a woman ahead of me that there was a problem with her motherboard on her current desktop, and the only solution was to purchase a new machine. From Best Buy. And then, because all their machines have Windows Vista on them, and the lady did not previously have Vista, she'll have to purchase all new software. From Best Buy. And she'll have to have all her old files transferred over to the new machine. For $99. From Best Buy. Or Something
6.
I should have said something to the woman, perhaps, but I was a little stunned, next in line, and not completely sure of myself. For example, I
think that with the help of someone with some computer expertise, she could probably just install a new motherboard. Worse case scenario, this person fails, and she's out one motherboard, which on
pricewatch.com ranges from about $300 to about $30, depending on your needs. I also
think that Vista might be
backwards compatible (4th paragraph in) with some Windows XP software, but then again I don't know what she was running. Finally, I'd imagine someone
supposedly knowledgeable in computer hardware could install her old hard drive as a second drive in her new computer, so she could access them without paying for a transfer and ending up with a drive she won't know what to do with.
Nah.
So I approach the agent next, unaware that a NAD was looming, just out of sight, behind the counter. I tell him my problem, and he informs me that the problem can be fixed, but I'll want to have my data backed up first. For $99. Or, if I'm up to it, if I think I can master the challenge, scale that peak which is data retention, and yea,
burn something to a CD, then I'm welcome to do it myself.
Wait, what?
My exterior is broken. Yes, but they'll want to fix it in the fastest way possible. But the problem is around the monitor. Yes, but if they decide to replace the hard drive, I'll get a new one back and have lost everything. Why on earth would they provide me with a new hard drive for a broken exterior?
Because in some cases, the fastest way to fix a broken computer is not to put your hard drive in a working computer and send it to you, but to put a new hard drive in your broken, old computer, and then extort you in any way possible
7.
So, according to the Geek Squad employee at this Best Buy, company policy is to issue a warning that your hard drive might at any moment be removed and sacrificed to some ancient god
8 the second it leaves your hands, without warning, consent, or particular attention to personal hygiene (he was kinda oily).
Recent Developments: Not taking this NAD lying down, I took my computer home. This morning I called the national hot line and told a very nice lady my tale of woe. Her immediate response was "Um, I don't think that's a company policy. Can I go talk to my supervisor?" I always like it when people like that ask me permission. It makes me feel as though I could say "No! Now pray with me, to the great god Odin!" Luckily for her, I kept my proselytizing in check, unlike certain
Evangelical Christian Cadets at the United States Air Force Academy. When she was back from her conference, she informed me that in fact saying that the hard drive needed to be backed up was not company policy, and that if the people servicing my laptop decided they needed to to anything to the hard drive, they would have to contact me and get my permission before doing so.
I immediately felt relief that this agent solved my dilemma, instead of presenting me with another NAD.
Conclusion: I head back to Best Buy today. I feel better armed with this knowledge, and if I encounter any more NADs, I will deal with them in the appropriate manner. I also feel better about the Geek Squad as a company, since this is probably just the doing of a single employee, and not the result from a culture in higher management, demanding that they make as much money as possible, and leaving it up to the people on the "ground" to figure out how, regardless of ethics.
Besides, they've never had any other
NADs.
Have you ever had to deal with some NADs
9? Tell us your tale in the comments section!